ANVILFIELD Try FieldOS

Roofing

Roof storm and hail damage assessment and insurance restoration field guide

How a roofer reads real hail and wind damage, documents the storm claim, and works it ethically and legally: ACV vs RCV, the deductible, supplements, and staying out of public adjusting.

Storm RestorationHail DamageInsurance ClaimACV vs RCVRoofing

Direct answer

Assess storm damage by identifying the roof product, documenting physical changes and their effect on water shedding or service life, and mapping the affected area. Haag's hail inspection protocol uses 100-square-foot test areas selected by roof direction and condition; Atlas calls for dated photographs and checks for hidden shingle fractures. The contractor reports the technical findings and repair scope; the insurer determines coverage under the policy and applicable law.

On this pageStorm restoration, and why the assessment is the jobTechnical findings and insurance coverage are separate decisionsWhy the assessment, not the roof, is the hard partWhat does real hail damage look like on a roof?Wind damage: creased, lifted, torn, and missing shinglesTelling real damage from cosmetic and old wearWhat evidence separates functional and cosmetic damage?The storm inspection methodHow does the investigation change by roof product?Documenting the damage for the claimDated photography and repeatable samplingWorked sampling record: count shingles separately from marksThe date of loss and verifying the stormHow the insurance claim process worksMeeting the adjuster on the roofWhat is the difference between ACV and RCV?Depreciation, the holdback, and the final paymentThe deductible and the payment recordSupplements: documenting changes to repair scopeCode upgrades and matchingWhy a contractor is not a public adjusterStorm chasers and the fraud to avoidThe contract and the contingency agreementThe ethics that keep you in businessDoing the approved work and releasing the depreciationThe records that hold the whole job togetherCommon mistakesField checklistStandards and referencesUnits, terms, and referencesSources checked and update record

Key takeaways

  • Haag's protocol uses 100-square-foot test areas selected by roof direction and condition, with damaged shingles counted separately from individual impact marks.
  • Inspect collateral surfaces for impact evidence and check the roof product for functional damage, since a soft spot, circular mark or dented gutter alone does not establish shingle damage.
  • The Texas Department of Insurance prohibits contractors from offering to waive, rebate or absorb a property insurance deductible.
  • Use NOAA storm records, the owner's account, prior roof records and physical findings to assess storm attribution, recording discovery and inspection dates separately.
  • The Texas Department of Insurance prohibits a contractor from adjusting a claim on property where that contractor provides or may provide contracting services.

Storm restoration, and why the assessment is the job

Storm restoration is the work of finding and documenting real hail or wind damage after a storm, providing the homeowner with evidence for an insurance claim, and repairing or replacing damaged roofing to a documented scope. The roof replacement is the visible part. The part that decides whether the job is honest is the assessment and the paperwork that come first.

Storm assessment means telling real hail and wind damage from cosmetic marking and ordinary age, photographing it the way a claim file needs, understanding how the money works through ACV, RCV, depreciation, and the deductible, and staying inside the law while you do it. The field draws storm chasers because the money moves fast after a big hail event, and a contractor who does not know the line between assessment and adjusting can break the law without meaning to.

Two sibling guides carry the rest. The roof inspection and maintenance program guide covers how a roof is walked and what condition looks like across its life, and the roof leak diagnosis guide covers tracing an active leak to its entry. This guide is about what happens after a storm: the damage call, the claim, and the ethics around both.

Technical findings and insurance coverage are separate decisions

The technical report answers what changed, what caused it, how much roofing is affected, and what repair restores performance. The coverage decision answers whether the policy pays, which exclusions apply, and how the loss is settled. Keep these conclusions in separate fields so a documented fracture does not become an unsupported promise of replacement coverage.

Haag's Assessing Hail Damage, Part 1, September 2019, separates physical findings from insurance policy definitions. Report appearance changes, impaired water shedding and reduced service life individually, with the supporting observations. An insurer's cosmetic exclusion uses the wording in that policy; it is not a field test for a broken roof.

The Texas Department of Insurance prohibits contractors from acting as public adjusters on property where they provide or may provide contracting services. Use the applicable state's licensing rules to assign claim representation, and give the homeowner the photographs, quantities and repair details needed to present the loss.

Why the assessment, not the roof, is the hard part

The roof is the easy part of storm restoration. A competent crew can tear off and replace a shingle roof. What separates an honest contractor from a liability is the call made before the tear-off: what physical damage is present, what evidence ties it to the storm, and what repair restores the roof.

An unsupported damage call sends the claim in the wrong direction. Calling wear a storm impact misstates the cause; overlooking a fracture leaves a damaged component out of the repair scope. Deliberately inventing damage is different from a diagnostic error, and neither belongs in the report.

So the skills that matter are diagnostic and ethical. Read the damage honestly. Document it so a stranger at a desk can see what you saw. Understand the money well enough to explain the process without crossing into adjusting it. Carry the same care into the repair and completion record.

What does real hail damage look like on a roof?

Haag's hail inspection protocol identifies shingle bruises as fractures of the reinforcing mat and also recognizes punctures and hail-caused granule displacement sufficient to expose substantial coating bitumen. A dark spot or soft feel alone does not establish a hail fracture. Record the surface condition, support beneath the shingle and evidence of mat rupture; Atlas's Detecting Hail Damage bulletin calls for careful underside inspection because fractures can be hidden beneath intact granules.

The pattern is the other half of the call. Haag compares suspected roof impacts with collateral surfaces and the distribution of hail effects across the property. Map sheltered and exposed areas, compare impact frequency, and distinguish scattered impacts from traffic paths or repeating installation defects. Shape alone does not identify hail, and wind-driven hail does not strike every slope equally.

Describe the affected component and the performance consequence before recommending a repair. Repairability, extent of physical damage and compatibility of replacement materials are technical findings. Whether insurance funds that repair or a larger replacement is a separate coverage decision.

Wind damage: creased, lifted, torn, and missing shingles

Wind damage shows as shingles that are creased, folded, torn, lifted or missing, and as failed sealant bonds that need their own cause assessment. IBHS's Natural Weathering and Hazard Exposure research identifies the shingle sealant bond as resistance to wind uplift and documents its deterioration with age. Record mat fractures, fastener damage and bond failures separately so the report explains which component failed.

Map creased, torn and missing shingles by roof plane, edge and corner, then compare them with attachment and seal conditions. Roof geometry and exposure affect uplift, so the slope facing the reported wind is not the only place to inspect. Record the observed damage distribution before assigning its cause.

An unsealed tab alone does not identify the cause of bond failure. Compare sealant condition, contamination, installation pattern and prior photographs with the storm history and surrounding damage. Record whether a bond never formed, deteriorated with age or broke during the event, and specify seal restoration or shingle replacement from the installed product's instructions. Keep that repair finding separate from the coverage decision.

Telling real damage from cosmetic and old wear

Separate storm-caused appearance changes from impairment of water shedding or service life. Haag's protocol recognizes significant hail-caused loss of protective granules as potential service-life damage even without a mat fracture. Record the size and extent of exposed asphalt, the surrounding weathering and the reason the loss is attributed to hail; do not classify every intact mat as cosmetic.

Several things mimic hail and are not hail. Blisters are bubbles in the asphalt from trapped moisture or off-gassing, round like a hail hit but with no mat fracture, often with the granules popped off in a ring rather than driven into the mat. Foot traffic scuffs and polishes the granules in a path. Manufacturing flaws, granule clumping, and the normal granule loss of age all read as damage to an untrained eye. None of them are storm caused.

The honest call is the one you can defend with a photo and a straight face to the adjuster, the carrier, and a fraud investigator if it comes to that. The Texas Department of Insurance says insurers do not pay for a new roof just because it is old or worn out. When a roof is simply worn out, say so, and let the homeowner decide what to do with that. What the policy actually covers is for the policy and the carrier to determine, not the contractor.

What evidence separates functional and cosmetic damage?

Describe the observed change before assigning a damage category. The following comparison applies Haag's causation method, Atlas's shingle investigation guidance and the metal-roof field and laboratory research published by IIBEC. Record the performance consequence and its evidence in separate columns.

Observed conditionEvidence to recordTechnical conclusion
Shingle bruise or punctureSurface and underside views, mat fracture, support and collateral impactsA verified hail-caused fracture or puncture supports a damaged-shingle finding.
Granule displacementExtent of asphalt exposure, surrounding wear, distribution and impact evidenceAssess loss of protection and service life; a dark spot alone is not enough.
Metal dentPanel profile, seam and lap condition, coating continuity, attachment and leakageA dent can change appearance while leaving function intact; seam distortion or penetration is a separate defect.
Blister, scuff or weatheringTraffic paths, repeated pattern, pre-storm images and comparison areasIdentify the competing cause and exclude it from hail quantities when supported.
No current leakIntegrity of the material and concealed layers, not just interior stainsA dry interior does not resolve whether impact fractured the roofing.

The storm inspection method

A storm inspection works the whole envelope, not just the shingles. Haag's protocol begins with collateral surfaces such as gutters, downspouts, vents, fences and condenser fins, then examines vulnerable roof details and field areas. Record dents as evidence of impact and compare their condition and distribution with the roofing. Dent diameter is not a direct measurement of hailstone diameter; material, support and impact conditions affect the mark.

Haag's published protocol uses 100-square-foot test areas, commonly 10 ft by 10 ft, with at least one representative area for each roof direction and additional areas where age, pitch or condition differs. Select unobstructed areas where possible and record why each location represents its roof zone. Count damaged shingles separately from individual marks, and inspect poorly supported ridges, valleys and edges separately from the field. Photograph each area before adding chalk annotations.

The inspection and maintenance program guide covers the full envelope walk and what condition looks like over a roof's life. On a storm call you run that same walk with one added question on every detail: is this fresh and storm caused, or was it here before.

How does the investigation change by roof product?

Identify the installed product before deciding which observations establish damage. Record manufacturer, product name, reinforcement, surfacing, substrate and repair history from labels, invoices and roof records. Use the exact product instructions to plan openings and repairs; a shingle bruise test does not assess a metal seam or a single-ply lap.

Atlas's Detecting Hail Damage bulletin directs careful lifting of selected shingles to look for concealed substrate ruptures. Obtain authorization for opening the assembly and document any seal disturbed during inspection. Record the observed underside condition and restore the disturbed location using the product's repair instructions.

Haag's Identifying Hail-Caused Fractures in Thermoplastic Roofing, February 2018, directs examination at underlying stress-plate edges, unsupported base flashings and gaps or unevenness in insulation boards. On TPO and PVC, locate impacts from spatter marks and insulation dents, then examine the membrane for tight circular or semicircular fractures. Record membrane integrity and insulation condition separately; an insulation dent is not itself proof of a membrane fracture.

Johns Manville's Protect Your JM Roof Guarantee brochure, RS-7395, March 2026, directs inspection after hail and other unusual events and identifies laps, flashings, drains and interior deterioration as inspection points. For a membrane roof, record the assembly beneath an impact as well as the surface. A suspected concealed defect needs a defined investigation question, a mapped opening or sample, and a compatible permanent repair.

Roof productProduct-specific examinationReport or repair decision
Asphalt shinglesAtlas: compare granule condition with underside substrate ruptureMap fractured shingles and identify the replacement product and seal restoration.
Metal panelsIIBEC metal-roof research: examine dents, coating, side/end laps and standing seamsSeparate visible denting from punctures, distorted joints and loss of water shedding.
TPO or PVC membraneHaag, February 2018: inspect impact locations, stress-plate edges, unsupported flashings and insulation-board gapsMap membrane fractures separately from insulation dents and identify the thermoplastic before specifying a repair.
EPDM membraneJM maintenance guidance: inspect field membrane, laps, flashings and drainageRecord tears and joint defects, identify the installed assembly and specify compatible repair materials.
Bituminous or surfaced low-slope roofHaag, September 2019: distinguish fractured membrane or base flashing from ruptured coating and displaced granulesRecord the affected layer, reinforcement and surfacing; match openings and repairs to the installed product.
Wood shingles or shakesHaag's assessment protocol: compare impact-associated fresh splits and punctures with weathering and footfall damageMap damaged units and exposed underlying layers; document inspection disturbance separately.

Documenting the damage for the claim

Documentation is the product of a storm assessment because the report must show both the condition and its location. Atlas's Detecting Hail Damage bulletin calls for multiple dated roof photographs when damage is suspected but not immediately visible. Keep the reported storm date, discovery date and inspection date separate. Capture building and slope overviews, intermediate location views and close-ups with scale, then connect them with a roof-plan reference.

Label photographs as you go. Retain original files and their capture metadata, and keep annotated copies separate so arrows and chalk labels do not replace the original evidence. Measurements belong in the file too: roof area, slopes, squares, accessories and sampled areas, so the repair quantities can be checked against the carrier's estimate.

Keep a photo register with the file name, capture date and time, roof plane, defect ID, scale, observation and any later alteration to the image. Record temporary patches and inspection disturbance with before-and-after photographs. The record is what survives the claim, the supplement and any dispute.

Dated photography and repeatable sampling

Use a sampling plan that another inspector can repeat. Record roof direction, product, age or installation phase, slope, support, exposure and sample boundaries before classifying the marks. Keep different roof conditions in separate groups; additional samples resolve variation rather than merely adding more photographs of the worst area.

For each test area, log its dimensions, location, observed marks, confirmed damaged shingles and excluded conditions. Record a damaged shingle once even when it contains several impacts, and keep ridge, valley and edge findings outside the field-area total. Haag's Test Square Method, April 2019, projects damaged units by multiplying damaged shingles per square by the roof area in squares for each direction. Group samples by product and condition before calculating a density or projected quantity.

Atlas directs inspectors to take dated photographs when damage is suspected but not immediately visible and to monitor for later granule loss. Revisit the same mapped locations and record new storms, maintenance and traffic between visits. The chronology distinguishes a newly documented condition from a confidently dated cause.

For an authorized material sample, record the exact removal point, orientation, layer sequence, collection date, collector, packaging and each transfer to the laboratory. Photograph the sample in place and after removal, retain a comparison sample when the investigation calls for one, and document the permanent repair of the opening. Agree on the question the laboratory will answer before removing material.

Record fieldWhat to enterWhy it matters
ChronologyReported event, discovery, inspection and revisit datesKeeps image capture time separate from loss attribution
Sample locationRoof-plan ID, direction, boundaries and measured areaAllows the same area to be found again
Condition countMarks, damaged shingles and excluded conditions separatelyPrevents multiple hits from becoming multiple replacement units
Photo registerOriginal file name, date/time, viewpoint, scale and defect IDConnects overview, close-up and later inspection
Material sampleLocation, orientation, custody record and opening repairPreserves traceability from roof to laboratory

Worked sampling record: count shingles separately from marks

Haag's October 2019 protocol uses 100-square-foot test areas, commonly 10 ft by 10 ft. Its Protocol for Assessment of Hail-Damaged Roofing conference paper gives worked inputs of an average 10 damaged shingles per square on a 30-square roof with comparable slope conditions. Anvilfield estimates 300 damaged shingles from those inputs by multiplying the average damaged-shingle count per square by the roof area in squares.

Method: multiply test-area length by width to obtain 100 square feet, then multiply 10 damaged shingles per square by 30 squares to obtain 300 projected damaged shingles. Keep the counted shingles distinct from individual impact marks and label the roof-wide quantity as an estimate. Where direction, age, material or condition differs, calculate each roof zone separately and add the separately inspected ridge, valley and edge quantities to the repair record.

Worked input or resultValueUse
Test-area length and width10 ft by 10 ftHaag's common test-area geometry
Calculated test area100 square feetLength multiplied by width; one roofing square
Average damaged-shingle count10 shingles per squareHaag conference-paper worked input; count each damaged shingle once
Roof area with comparable conditions30 squaresHaag conference-paper worked input
Anvilfield estimates damaged shingles300 shingles10 damaged shingles per square multiplied by 30 squares
Repair specificationMapped components and compatible repair detailsCombine projected field quantities with separately inspected details and repairability findings

The date of loss and verifying the storm

The date of loss is the date of the damaging event; record discovery and inspection dates separately. NOAA's Storm Data format identifies event times, time zones, report sources, locations and narratives. Save those fields with the event identifier and compare the reported location with the property. Regional weather evidence supports the event history; linking a particular roof defect to that event requires the physical inspection.

Compare the event record with owner accounts, prior inspection photographs, maintenance history and collateral impacts. Label the storm date as reported or supported by the evidence available. Where the roof shows effects from different events, describe those findings separately instead of assigning every mark to the latest storm.

The Texas Department of Insurance advises reporting property damage as soon as possible. Record the policy's notice and proof-of-loss deadlines, the reporting date and the insurer's acknowledgment in the file. Begin temporary protection and preserve its receipts and photographs while the claim is investigated.

How the insurance claim process works

The insurance claim is the homeowner's to file and work, and the contractor's role is to assess and document, not to run the claim. The homeowner contacts their carrier, reports the loss with the date and what happened, and the carrier assigns an adjuster who inspects the roof and writes a scope of loss, usually in estimating software such as Xactimate. The carrier then issues a payment based on that scope and the policy terms.

The steps the homeowner takes, filing, allowing the inspection, reviewing the scope, agreeing or disputing, are theirs. The contractor supports each step with the damage documentation and a clear repair estimate, and stays out of the parts the law reserves for licensed people. When the homeowner disagrees with the carrier's scope or a denial, they can request the insurer's review, use the policy's dispute process, or engage an authorized representative. The contractor supplies the technical evidence.

This division is not a formality. It is where the legal line sits. Texas Department of Insurance guidance prohibits contractors from negotiating settlements or speaking for policyholders on coverage when they also provide the contracting services. The applicable state's rules govern claim representation.

Meeting the adjuster on the roof

Meet the adjuster on the roof and present your documentation, professionally, as the contractor who inspected it. This is the contractor's legitimate role in the claim: be there, show the test squares you chalked, point out the bruises and the creased tabs, and walk the collateral impact marks that support the event history. You are providing the inspection and the evidence, not adjusting the claim.

Present clear documentation and record any disagreement about physical conditions with the defect IDs and photographs. Explain the labor, materials and quantities in your repair estimate. Keep requests for coverage determinations separate from technical explanations of the work.

Where the contractor and the adjuster genuinely disagree on what is covered or what it is worth, that is the homeowner's dispute to escalate, through the policy's process, a licensed public adjuster, or an attorney. The contractor's job is to make sure nothing real gets missed because it was not documented, not to win the negotiation.

What is the difference between ACV and RCV?

The Texas Department of Insurance describes replacement cost coverage as payment to repair or replace covered property at current costs, subject to policy limits. For residential fire and extended-coverage losses settled on actual cash value, NAIC's July 1997 model regulation, Section 9B(1), defines ACV as replacement cost at the time of loss less depreciation. The deductible reduces the claim payment separately; it is not part of depreciation or the ACV valuation. On a replacement cost policy, an initial payment commonly reflects ACV less the applicable deductible, with recoverable depreciation paid when the policy settlement conditions are met.

An ACV-only policy settles covered damage on the depreciated valuation without the replacement-cost holdback. Keep the insurer's valuation, depreciation, deductible and net payment on separate lines so the homeowner can reconcile the estimate with the payment record.

This is the part homeowners understand least and contractors most often explain wrong, so explain the mechanism and stop there. How much depreciation applies, whether it is recoverable, and what the policy actually pays are set by the policy language and the carrier, not by the contractor. A contractor who promises a homeowner a specific number is guessing at someone else's math.

For what the policy owes and any argument about it, the homeowner relies on the policy, a licensed public adjuster, or an attorney. The contractor explains how the two-check structure generally works so the homeowner is not surprised, then points them to the policy and a licensed professional for what their claim is worth.

TermWhat it isHow it pays
RCVReplacement cost of the roof todayCovered replacement cost subject to deductible, limits and policy settlement conditions
ACVRCV minus depreciation for age and wearACV is a valuation; an initial payment generally subtracts the applicable deductible
Recoverable depreciationDepreciation held back on the first checkPaid when the policy conditions for recovery are met
Non-recoverable depreciationDepreciation that is never paidStays with the carrier
DeductibleThe homeowner's share of the lossSubtracted before payment; owed by the homeowner

Depreciation, the holdback, and the final payment

Depreciation is the amount the carrier subtracts from replacement cost for the roof's age and condition, and on a replacement cost policy a chunk of it is usually recoverable. Recoverable depreciation is held back on the initial payment and released under the policy settlement conditions. The Texas Department of Insurance describes staged roof-claim payments, with the remaining payment following the start of repairs; the policy specifies the evidence needed. Non-recoverable depreciation is gone for good, never paid, on the items or policies where it applies.

The sequence is straightforward to describe. The carrier values the covered repair or replacement, applies depreciation and the deductible to the initial payment, and identifies any depreciation recoverable under the policy. The homeowner submits the required repair and payment evidence to recover the eligible holdback. Keep the insurer's stated recovery conditions and deadline with that evidence.

What is recoverable, the deadline to claim it, and the proof required are policy terms, so confirm them against the actual policy. The contractor's part is to complete the approved work and provide the clean completion documentation that lets the homeowner collect the holdback. The numbers themselves belong to the policy and the carrier.

The deductible and the payment record

The deductible is the homeowner's share of a covered loss. The Texas Department of Insurance states that Texas prohibits contractors from offering to waive, rebate or absorb it; the agency identifies Insurance Code Chapter 707 and Business and Commerce Code 27.02 as the governing provisions. State the applicable jurisdiction when explaining a legal prohibition.

Keep the invoice and payment record accurate. A discount must not be hidden behind an inflated invoice submitted as the amount actually charged. In Texas, the insurer may request evidence that the homeowner paid the deductible.

The homeowner's deductible obligation follows the policy and applicable law. Keep the applicable deductible provision, the amount actually charged and payment evidence in the file. A contractor's invoice must accurately show discounts and payments.

The Texas Department of Insurance explains that a home-policy deductible can be a fixed amount or a percentage of the insured property value. Read the wind and hail deductible on the declarations and endorsements, including its calculation base. A percentage of dwelling coverage is different from the same percentage of repair cost.

Supplements: documenting changes to repair scope

A supplement supplies evidence for repair items or quantities missing from the carrier's estimate. Record extra layers found at tear-off, flashing and accessories, access conditions and the adopted-code provisions supporting required work. Identify deteriorated decking separately from storm-caused damage, even when both need repair, so the construction scope does not imply that every item is insured.

A technical supplement explains the labor, materials, quantities and repair method, with photographs and supporting records. Texas Department of Insurance guidance prohibits contractors who provide or may provide the repairs from negotiating claim settlements or speaking for the homeowner on coverage. Supplying a repair estimate does not authorize claim representation; follow the applicable state's rules for the communication itself.

Compare the two scopes line by line and document each discrepancy with its location, measured quantity and repair reason. Keep requests about coverage and settlement with the homeowner or the representative permitted by state law. Preserve photographs and records of concealed conditions before the repair covers them.

Code upgrades and matching

Separate required construction work from insurance reimbursement. Identify the locally adopted code provision and the existing roof condition that triggers each proposed upgrade, such as deck attachment, flashing or ventilation work. Record ordinance-and-law coverage and limits in the claim file separately from the repair specification.

Matching concerns the appearance of repaired and retained materials. For replacement-cost settlement, NAIC's Unfair Property/Casualty Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation, July 1997, Section 9A(2), calls for replacement of items within the affected area to achieve reasonably uniform appearance when replacements differ in quality, color or size. An adopted state rule and the policy establish the applicable obligation; the NAIC text is a model. Document the existing product, available replacement, visible mismatch and applicable provision separately.

The contractor's part is to identify the code items the job actually requires and to document the matching problem accurately. Whether the policy pays for either is a coverage question for the policy, the carrier, and, in a dispute, a licensed public adjuster or attorney.

Why a contractor is not a public adjuster

The Texas Department of Insurance states that a contractor cannot act as a public insurance adjuster on property where the contractor provides or may provide contracting services. The restriction includes advertising that role, negotiating settlements and speaking for the homeowner about coverage. Keep the applicable state licensing rule with the claim file rather than presenting a national rule or a nationwide criminal penalty.

The reason is conflict of interest as much as licensing. A contractor who profits from the repair has every incentive to inflate the claim, and Texas law separates the contractor and public-adjuster roles on the same property. The contractor assesses, documents, and builds the roof. That is the lane.

Present the damage documentation and the estimate for the work. Keep coverage disputes and settlement representation with the homeowner and the representative permitted under the applicable state's law. A technical supplement explains why an item is needed; it does not authorize the contractor to settle the claim.

Storm chasers and the fraud to avoid

Judge a storm contractor by verifiable identity, documented findings, written scope and completed work, rather than the location of its office. The Texas Department of Insurance recommends comparing multiple contractor bids with the adjuster's report. Pressure to sign before reviewing the scope and payment terms is a reason to stop the sale.

The patterns repeat. The free inspection that always finds damage, real or manufactured. The offer to waive or cover the deductible, which Texas expressly prohibits. The pressure to sign on the spot, often an assignment of benefits that hands the contractor control of the claim, the money, and the scope before anyone has agreed on the work. Manufactured damage, where the inspector creates the hits they then photograph. Targeting elderly homeowners. None of it protects the homeowner, and all of it eventually burns the contractor's name.

Protect the homeowner by documenting honestly, respecting the applicable deductible law, and leaving control of the claim with the homeowner. The Georgia Attorney General's cancellation guidance describes three business days to cancel qualifying off-premises consumer sales and identifies exceptions, including emergency home repairs. An at-home signature alone does not establish a cancellation right; record the applicable rule and cancellation notice in the contract file.

The contract and the contingency agreement

A contingency agreement should state exactly what event authorizes the roofing work, what happens if insurance denies or limits the claim, and what separately authorized work the homeowner must pay for. A denied claim does not automatically create a deductible payment owed to the contractor. Keep emergency repairs, inspection charges and the eventual roof contract distinct in the written agreement.

Read the assignment of benefits clause carefully, or avoid it. An assignment of benefits transfers the homeowner's claim rights to the contractor, and in the wrong hands it is the instrument behind much storm-chaser abuse, which is why several states have restricted it. A homeowner generally keeps more control by not signing one. Whether an assignment of benefits is enforceable, and on what terms, is state law, so the rule on it is the rule in the state where the property sits.

The contract should state the scope clearly, state the agreed price and how approved changes are authorized, name the deductible as the homeowner's, and avoid language that quietly hands over the claim. Anything about the legal effect of a clause is a question for an attorney, not the contractor's to opine on. Keep the agreement honest and let the homeowner read it without pressure.

The ethics that keep you in business

Ethics in storm restoration come down to a few hard rules that also happen to keep you out of court: assess damage honestly, never invent or exaggerate it, never touch the deductible, stay out of adjusting, and keep the homeowner's interest ahead of the quick dollar. The storm chaser works a short game and leaves. The contractor who plans to be in the same county in ten years works a long one.

Accurate records protect the homeowner and the contractor. Preserve unfavorable findings as well as favorable ones, identify pre-existing deterioration, and correct mistakes in writing. Consistent documentation makes the repair recommendation easier to review.

Build the documented repair correctly and retain the payment and completion records. Tell the truth about the damage, do the work right, and let the licensed people handle what the law gives them.

Doing the approved work and releasing the depreciation

The repair is the part the homeowner can see, so build it to the approved scope, to the locally adopted code, and to a quality that holds up, and document completion to support the policy settlement process. Pull the permits the jurisdiction requires, install to the manufacturer's instructions and document the applicable warranty conditions, and resolve any difference between the approved estimate and required construction before proceeding.

The final inspection matters twice: once for the building department where one is required, and once as the documentation that the work was completed to scope. Give the homeowner the final invoice, payment evidence and finished-roof photographs for the insurer's settlement requirements. The policy establishes which records trigger payment of recoverable depreciation and when they are due.

The roof inspection and maintenance program guide covers how that new roof should be walked and maintained from day one to reach its design life, and the leak diagnosis guide covers tracing any leak that shows up later to its real entry. A new warranty is only as good as the maintenance behind it, so hand the homeowner that file and that habit along with the roof.

The records that hold the whole job together

The records are what turn a storm job from a series of phone calls into something that survives an audit, a supplement, or a dispute years out. One organized file per property carries the inspection and its photos, the documentation of the damage, the date of loss and storm verification, the claim and the approved scope, the supplements, and the completion record that released the depreciation. Lose any piece and you are reconstructing it from memory when someone asks.

Keep originals, annotations, measurements, sampling records, repair details and completion documents together. Johns Manville's roof maintenance guidance calls for retaining inspection and activity records. The table below organizes that evidence for the owner, insurer and any later technical review.

ItemWhatNote
Date of lossStorm date and verificationReported event date, weather record and physical causation evidence; discovery date kept separately
Inspection photosTest squares, bruises, creases, soft metalsOriginals dated and located, with scale; annotations stored separately
MeasurementsRoof area, slopes, squares, accessoriesLets the scope be built and checked
Claim and scopeCarrier scope of loss and claim numberThe approved work, line by line
SupplementsMissed and code scope, with proofDocuments the work, not the claim's value
ContractAgreed scope, payment terms, change authorization and deductibleDeductible is the homeowner's; no assignment-of-benefits pressure
Completion recordFinal invoice, payment proof, finished photosSupports recovery under the policy settlement conditions

Common mistakes

  • Inventing or exaggerating damage, or calling old wear and blisters a storm hit.
  • Offering a deductible waiver where prohibited, or submitting an invoice that conceals the amount actually charged.
  • Acting as an unlicensed public adjuster by negotiating, interpreting coverage, or settling the claim.
  • Selecting only the worst-looking sample area or counting every surface mark as a damaged shingle.
  • Poor documentation: photos with no date, no location, no scale, and no hit count, that sink the claim.
  • Pushing an assignment of benefits or pressuring a signature on the spot, storm-chaser style.
  • Promising the homeowner a specific payout or interpreting their policy instead of pointing them to it.
  • Padding a supplement with scope the photos do not support.
  • Building below the approved scope or skipping code items to inflate margin.

Field checklist

0 of 11 complete

Want this checklist to run itself on every job — with photo proof and a signed record crews can hand the customer? That's FieldOS.

Standards and references

There is no single code that runs a storm claim. The framework is the homeowner's policy, state insurance law, and a few industry references, and the policy and state law control every point about coverage and money.

The homeowner's policy is the document that decides the claim: what perils are covered, ACV versus RCV, the deductible, depreciation, any cosmetic exclusion, and any code-upgrade or matching endorsement. For interpreting it or disputing the carrier, the homeowner relies on a licensed public adjuster or an attorney, not the contractor. State insurance law governs who may adjust a claim, whether a deductible can be touched, and how an assignment of benefits works, and it varies enough that the only safe rule is the one in the state where the property sits. The Texas Department of Insurance guidance cited here documents Texas restrictions; identify the governing rule for the property jurisdiction.

Use Haag's inspection protocol for comparative hail assessment and its thermoplastic-roofing article for tight impact fractures, Atlas's shingle bulletin for hidden fracture checks and dated monitoring, and Johns Manville's maintenance guidance for membrane laps, flashings and drainage inspection. IBHS's weathering research explains aging sealant bonds; the metal-roof study published by IIBEC distinguishes dents from impaired joints. Match the product and assembly to the manufacturer's instructions before specifying a repair.

Units, terms, and references

Storm restoration borrows terms from roofing, insurance, and law, and the same word can mean different things across an estimate, a policy, and a statute, so the terms are worth pinning down.

Haag's protocol counts damaged shingles in a roofing square of 100 square feet. Describe functional effects as impaired water shedding or reduced service life, and appearance effects as visible changes without established performance loss. The money terms, ACV, RCV, depreciation, recoverable depreciation, deductible, and supplement, are defined below as they are used in a claim, but the policy's own definitions control.

Storm restoration
Assessing and documenting storm damage, supplying repair evidence for the claim, and repairing or replacing affected roofing
Functional vs cosmetic damage
Functional effects impair water shedding or service life; appearance changes are recorded separately from policy-specific cosmetic exclusions
Hail vs wind damage
Hail assessment compares impact evidence with fractures, punctures and surface loss; wind assessment records creases, tears, missing shingles and seal conditions
ACV vs RCV
Actual cash value is replacement cost minus depreciation; replacement cost value is the full cost to replace the roof today
Recoverable depreciation
Depreciation withheld from the initial payment and recoverable when policy settlement conditions are met
Deductible
The insured share of a covered loss; Texas prohibits contractor offers to waive, rebate or absorb it
Supplement
A documented request to add real missed or code-required scope to the carrier's estimate, with proof
Public adjuster
A policyholder representative whose claim negotiation requires the license and role allowed by the applicable state
Date of loss
Date of the damaging event, supported by event history and physical evidence; recorded separately from discovery and inspection

Sources checked and update record

Reviewed November 6, 2026. Corrected hail causation, functional versus appearance damage, sampling, weather-record interpretation and blanket insurance statements. Expanded the product-specific investigation, dated evidence register and worked sampling calculation. Final review clarified wind-related bond failures, ACV versus net payment, replacement-cost matching and the separation of technical supplements from claim representation.

How to cite this page: Anvilfield, Roof storm and hail damage assessment and insurance restoration field guide, 2026, https://anvilfield.com/field-guides/roofing/roof-storm-hail-damage-insurance-restoration/.

Related tools

Calculators and readiness checks for this work

Next step: Find shingle restoration territory

FAQ

What is roof storm restoration?

Roof storm restoration covers everything after a hail or wind storm: the damage assessment, the documentation, supporting the homeowner's insurance claim, and the replacement to the approved scope. The contractor assesses and builds; the homeowner files and works the claim. Coverage and dollar questions belong to the policy, the carrier, and a licensed public adjuster or attorney.

What does hail damage look like on a roof?

Haag's inspection protocol looks for hail-caused bruises, punctures and substantial displacement of protective granules, supported by collateral evidence and comparison with other causes. Atlas also calls for underside checks because the reinforcing mat can rupture beneath intact surface granules. A soft spot, circular mark or dented gutter alone does not establish shingle damage.

What is the difference between ACV and RCV?

Replacement cost value, RCV, is the estimated cost to replace the roof; actual cash value, ACV, deducts depreciation for age and wear. NAIC's July 1997 model regulation, Section 9B(1), uses replacement cost at the time of loss less depreciation for residential fire and extended-coverage losses settled on ACV. A deductible reduces the claim payment separately. On replacement cost coverage, recoverable depreciation follows the policy's settlement conditions and required repair evidence.

Can a roofer waive my deductible?

Texas prohibits contractors from offering to waive, rebate or absorb a property insurance deductible, according to the Texas Department of Insurance. Identify the law for the state where the roof is located, and keep the invoice and payment record accurate. The deductible is the insured share of a covered loss.

Can a contractor negotiate my insurance claim?

The Texas Department of Insurance prohibits a contractor from adjusting an insurance claim on property where that contractor provides or may provide contracting services. The contractor supplies technical findings and a repair estimate. Claim representation follows the applicable state's licensing and conflict-of-interest rules.

What is recoverable depreciation on a roof claim?

Recoverable depreciation is the portion of depreciation payable when the policy settlement conditions are met. Keep the repair contract, invoices, payment evidence and completion photographs ready for the insurer's stated requirements. The Texas Department of Insurance describes staged payments for replacement-cost roof claims; the policy governs the recovery conditions and deadline.

How do I prove the storm date for a roof claim?

Save the weather event record, owner account and prior roof records, then compare them with the physical damage. NOAA Storm Data includes event times, locations, sources and narratives. A regional hail report supports storm history; the roof investigation supplies the evidence linking a defect to that event. Record discovery and inspection dates separately.

What is a roofing supplement?

A roofing supplement documents repair items or quantities missing from the carrier's estimate, with photographs, measurements and repair details. Examples include concealed roof layers, flashing, decking condition and code-required components. The contractor explains the work and its cost; the homeowner or authorized representative addresses what the policy pays. Texas Department of Insurance guidance prohibits a contractor who provides or may provide repairs from negotiating settlements or speaking for the homeowner on coverage.

How do I avoid a storm-chaser roofing scam?

Compare written bids, verify the contractor and reject invented damage or prohibited deductible waivers. Keep control of the claim and read cancellation and assignment terms before signing. Georgia's Attorney General describes a three-business-day cancellation period for qualifying off-premises consumer sales, with exceptions including emergency home repairs; an at-home signature alone does not guarantee that right.

Will insurance pay to match my undamaged shingles?

Matching payment follows the policy and applicable state law. For replacement-cost settlement, NAIC's July 1997 model regulation, Section 9A(2), calls for reasonably uniform appearance within the affected area when replacement items differ in quality, color or size. Document the existing shingle, available replacements and visible mismatch, then identify the adopted state rule and policy provision governing payment.

People also ask

Sources checked